Advocacy strategy · November 16, 2026

    One issue. Many angles. Same truth.

    Dark blue sea streaked with white foam, seen from above

    This is the second post in a series on advocacy strategy. The posts draw on a forthcoming book about the meeting point of strategic management and advocacy. The previous post asked why anyone else should care about your issue — and left open a question this post answers: how is the same need for change made meaningful in very different worlds without distorting the truth?

    One change, five questions

    Let us start with a new care model proposed for adoption by the regional health authorities. Different people respond to the proposal with different questions.

    A patient wonders whether the change will improve their care. A doctor weighs how the model would work in practice. The authority's leadership asks: can we actually implement this? At the Ministry of Finance, the question is who picks up the bill. And among many other things, an MP considers how the change could be justified to their voters.

    Each of the five is looking at the same change, yet none of them is looking at it from the same direction. For advocacy, this difference in vantage points yields two observations — one obvious, one less so.

    The first, obvious observation is that the same change cannot be understood from a single viewpoint. Answering the patient's question does not simultaneously answer the Ministry of Finance's concerns. The answer that convinced the doctor has not automatically given the MP a justification they can credibly make their own.

    The second, less obvious observation concerns a mistake I have seen many people make.

    Different angles do not mean different truths

    The advocate realises that different people and parties are asking different questions. Very often, that realisation leads to the conclusion:

    Let's tell each of them what they want to hear.

    In practice, this means talking to the ministry about costs, to the patient organisation about quality of care, and to the media about problems. There is nothing wrong with the realisation itself, or with the actions that follow. Things become a problem when the perspectives start to be treated in isolation from one another: the messages fragment into disconnected, perhaps even opportunistic, pieces. The real trouble begins if, along the way, the facts change, the promises change, or what is left unsaid about the essential consequences changes.

    The earlier care model example makes the problem concrete. If adopting the model increases the need for staff, that need does not disappear from the conversation about costs. And if there is not yet sufficient evidence of savings, they cannot be promised to one party as certain and described to another as a mere possibility.

    Blurring the facts can work for a while, but advocacy has one particular feature that leads to trouble in the end: people talk to each other. This is especially true in a country the size of Finland, where circles are small.

    In practice I mean, for example, that a civil servant reads the same statement the patient organisation was given. A journalist calls the ministry and reaches the official who knows that statement well. An MP, during committee hearings, asks an expert how things really stand. It is almost inevitable that, sooner or later, the versions meet. And when they do, you burn through the capital that is hardest of all to earn in advocacy — and hardest of all to rebuild.

    Trust.

    What matters most is that the other party must be able to assess the proposal on honest grounds — whether or not they ever compare our words with what others have heard. In advocacy, too, there is always a next day.

    Good advocacy does not build different truths for different audiences. It helps build a shared understanding of the same reality. New information may change our view — but a change of listener never justifies changing the facts or making contradictory promises. The angle changes. The truth does not.

    That is why the principle this post is built around is simple:

    One issue. Many angles. Same truth.

    The difference sounds small. In practice, it is what separates strategic advocacy from opportunistic messaging.

    Why do the perspectives differ?

    Why do the five people in our simplified care model example see the issue so differently?

    It is not that any of them is poorly prepared. Each of them views the issue through the responsibilities they carry — or the way it touches their own life.

    A company examines the model from the standpoint of its investments. A regulator focuses on legality. A politician weighs, among everything else, political acceptability. And a patient thinks about how the model will affect their daily life.

    All of them can be sincere at the same time. And each of them can, at the same time, see something the others cannot see from their own position.

    The historian E.H. Carr once made the same point with his mountain analogy: “It does not follow that, because a mountain appears to take on different shapes from different angles of vision, it has objectively either no shape at all or an infinity of shapes.”[1] Richard Evans later leaned on the same image when defending the objectivity of scholarship against radical relativism. The same holds in advocacy: the angles produce different pictures, but there is one mountain.

    Someone can still simply be wrong: factual claims can contradict each other, and when they do, time must be spent establishing which of them hold.

    An opposing view, however, is not automatically an error to be corrected. It is another perspective on the same reality: a different weighting of consequences, a different responsibility carried, a different assessment of risk. And it is important to recognise and understand it.

    The advocate's task, then, is not to explain other perspectives away. Rather, they must be able to justify why the proposed change is worth pursuing even when the alternatives and the downsides are taken into account. And if genuine flaws are found in the proposal, they must be fixed.

    It sounds simple — but two biases make organisations stumble over it time and again.

    Expert bias: we speak as if the other person were already there

    The first of the two I call expert bias: we assume the other person already knows and understands what we know and understand.

    Picture an expert who has spent the past three years studying and assessing the effects of a new piece of regulation. They know the legislation, the case law, the economic impacts and the international comparisons like the back of their hand. They are equally familiar with all the reasons why the current system is no longer fit for today.

    Yet when meeting a decision-maker, the expert starts from the point their own thinking has reached after three years of work.

    The decision-maker has not travelled that road. They may well be encountering the issue for the first time.

    The expert, in the role of advocate, speaks as if the listener were at the same point on the path of reasoning that they themselves reached over months or even years. In reality, in this example, the listener is still at the very start of the path.

    Organisational bias: we assume others are looking from the same place

    The second bias came up in the previous post. I call it organisational bias: we assume our own organisation's perspective is also the natural way for everyone else to make sense of the world.

    Expert bias is about the distance travelled: we assume the other person is already where we are. Organisational bias is about the vantage point: the other party is not looking at things from the place we are looking from. We assume that anyone given the same facts will find the problem as obvious as we do. That rarely happens: the same fact means one thing to the director of a regional health authority and another to a patient — one is responsible for the service system, the other experiences the change in their daily life.

    The path of reasoning must be made visible

    You can always tell someone your conclusion, but that does not yet explain how you reached it. That is why the reasoning behind it must also be laid open for others to assess — and, where necessary, to challenge. This is the observation that changed my own thinking about advocacy.

    I used to start from the idea that an advocate's most important task is to find the most convincing and compelling arguments.

    I now think differently.

    An advocate's most important task is to make visible how they arrived at their conclusion. And it has to be done in a way that allows others to understand, assess and challenge both the path of reasoning and the conclusion from their own starting points.

    I structure the reasoning path of an issue chosen for advocacy like this:

    Observation → Fact → Interpretation → Conclusion → Need for change

    Observation. Something seems to be wrong.

    Fact. Is the observation true more broadly? What do we know, and what do we not?

    Interpretation. What is causing it? What does this tell us about the system?

    Conclusion. If our interpretation holds, what follows?

    Need for change. What should change?

    The path is not one-way, because new information or a well-founded objection may require going back to an earlier step. In some situations, the proposal itself ends up being refined. It is worth bearing in mind that criticism is therefore not purely a bad thing. People who look at the issue from a different perspective can see something in the reasoning that we have missed. Filling in the gaps in the reasoning can itself strengthen trust between the parties.

    Many organisations jump straight from observation to proposal. The decision-maker, or any other listener, then never hears or grasps the path the advocate has walked over months or even years. A gap opens up that merely repeating the conclusion cannot bridge. The decision-maker may fill in the missing steps from their own experience — and, for that very reason, arrive at an entirely different conclusion.

    It is important to stress that opening up the chain of reasoning is not manipulation. Quite the opposite. It is making thinking visible.

    A good advocate does not ask others merely to accept their conclusion. They help others understand why this particular conclusion appears justified. At best, the reasoning has been thought through from the decision-maker's own premises. By this I do not mean putting words in the decision-maker's mouth, but recognising their premises and their thinking.

    When we present only the conclusion, we ask people to take our word for it. When we explain our reasoning, we help them form a reasoned view of their own.

    The latter can produce something that lasts even when we are not in the room.

    Where to start the conversation

    This leads to a practical rule that can be surprisingly hard to observe.

    Many advocacy efforts begin with a strong opinion: this law should be changed, current regulation stifles innovation, this solution would be better for society.

    These positions may be well founded, but a ready-made position does not yet reveal the observations and assumptions it rests on. Without them, the discussion easily becomes a defence of pre-formed views.

    That is why I would not start only by asking:

    What do we think about this?

    I would first ask:

    What is actually going on here?

    Same truth, different starting points

    The latter question does not leave the discussion at who is for and who is against. It invites us to examine together what we know, how we interpret it and what follows from it. To return to the care model example: examining the issue together can help find a conclusion that the doctor, the regional health authority and the Ministry of Finance can each justify from their own starting points.

    None of this means naively assuming that everyone will end up with the same opinion. At best, the different parties recognise the same need for change from their own starting points. It does not always happen: someone can understand the proposal well and still weigh the costs, or the order of priorities, differently. Even then, shared understanding makes visible where the disagreement really comes from — and whether the conditions for a joint solution exist.

    One issue. Many angles. Same truth.


    Shared understanding is necessary, but it is not yet enough. A decision-maker can understand the need for the change, consider the proposal a good one — and still not take it up as their own. The next post in the series asks why.

    Source

    [1] E. H. Carr: What Is History? (1961), chapter 1, “The Historian and His Facts”. On Richard J. Evans's use of Carr's mountain analogy, see David Stack: “Objectivity and the Historian: Beyond the Fried Egg Test”, Critical Quarterly (2025). https://doi.org/10.1111/criq.12824